Past Papers · SAQ
Creatinine & Renal Function
2022A Q07
Exam questionWrite notes comparing the use of serum creatinine and creatinine clearance in the assessment of renal function in the critically ill.
CICMWrecks answer
Master answer
Clearance:
- Renal clearance = vol of plasma completely cleared of a given substance by the kidneys per unit time (ml/min)
- Involves: glomerular filtration, secretion, reabsorption, and rarely tubular metabolism
- Renal clearance = V x [U]/[P]
- V = volume of urine or urine flow rate in ml/min
- [U] = urinary concentration of substance in mg/ml
- [P] = plasma concentration of substance in mg/ml
Estimating GFR:
- GFR = renal clearance of a substance if it is:
- Freely filtered at glomerulus
- Not secreted
- Not reabsorbed
- Not synthesized
- Not metabolised
- The amount excreted in the urine = amount filtered
- i.e. [plasma] x GFR = [urine] x urine vol
- Rearrange: GFR = urine vol x [urine] / [plasma]
Creatinine
- used to approximate GFR as is more practical
- Released at a steady state from skeletal muscle cells (phosphocreatine)
- Freely filtered + not reabsorbed.
- *Small amount secreted → overestimates GFR by small amount
- Serum creatinine levels can be used as a surrogate marker of GFR
- Creatinine clearance calculation better than creatinine levels
- most accurate to collect urine and use the formula to assess creatinine clearance
- because serum creatinine it is at steady state, eGFR can be calculated by Cockroft-Gault, MDRD or CKD-Epi
- During acute changes in GFR, serum creatinine will underestimate GFR until a new steady state is reached.
Creatinine Clearance Estimation from Serum Creatinine
- CG (Cockcroft-Gault Equation): common method which has a correlation of ~0.83 with CrCl:
- CrCl = [(140−A) × W x S)] / (72 × Cr) , where:
- Cl = Clearance (mL/min), A = Age, W = Lean body Wt (kg)
- S = Sex coefficient (Male = 1, Female = 0.85), Cr = Creatinine in µmol.L-1
- CrCl = [(140−A) × W x S)] / (72 × Cr) , where:
- Alternative formulas are MDRD and CKD-EPI. These equations have two advantages over Cockcroft-Gault:
- They are better predictors of GFR
- They do not require weight, and so can be calculated by the laboratory automatically, Other required data (gender, race, age, creatinine) can be taken from hospital records.
- MDRD (Modification of Diet in Renal Disease Study): useful in estimating glomerular filtration rate (GFR) in stable chronic kidney disease
- CKD-EPI (Chronic Kidney Disease Epidemiology Collaboration): more precise formula to estimate glomerular filtrate rate (GFR) from serum creatinine and other readily available clinical parameters, especially at when actual GFR is >60 mL/min per 1.73m2
Limitations
- General limitations
- Dependent on serum creatinine, which can be highly variable. Formulas are derived from average values of dependent variables, and so will be unreliable at extremes of:
- Age
- Muscle mass
- Critically ill
- Malignancy
- Diet (High production with red meat)
- the relationship between creatinine clearance and serum creatinine is non-linear
- filtration is only one component of a complex kidney, although GFR is used as a surrogate of function
- Small amount of creatinine is secreted by proximal tubule – so Creatinine clearance is ~10-20% higher than GFR
- More severely overestimates GFR in patients with very low GFR
- Dependent on serum creatinine, which can be highly variable. Formulas are derived from average values of dependent variables, and so will be unreliable at extremes of:
- Critically ill patients
- the amount of creatinine produced varies with muscle mass, nutrition, steroid use, muscle injury
- there can be a decline of almost 50% of function before serum creatinine levels rise
- they do not indicate dynamic changes in renal function
- are modified by aggressive fluid resuscitation
JC 2019
Past papers
Exam appearances
| Exam | Exact exam wording | Candidate success |
|---|---|---|
| 2022A Q07 | Write notes comparing the use of serum creatinine and creatinine clearance in the assessment of renal function in the critically ill. | 11% |
| 2013B Q11 | Describe the relationship between creatinine clearance and serum creatinine. (60% of marks) What are the limitations in using serum creatinine to assess renal function in the critically ill? (40% of marks) | — |
| 2008A Q13 | Describe the relationship between creatinine clearance and serum creatinine concentrations. What are the potential pitfalls in using serum creatinine concentrations to assess renal function in a critically ill patient in ICU? | — |