Past Papers · SAQ
Mannitol vs Hypertonic Saline
2015A Q10
Exam questionCompare and contrast the pharmacology of mannitol and hypertonic saline
CICMWrecks answer
Master answer
Master Compare
Compare candidate-facing canonical Pharmacopeia fields side by side. Isolated AI-draft proposals are never included.
| Field |
MANNITOL
Renal · Renal · Level 3
|
HYPERTONIC SALINE (3%)
Fluids & Electrolytes · Fluids & Electrolytes · Level 1
|
|---|---|---|
| Mechanism of action | osmotic agent. inc plasma osmolality and draws water out of the CSF and vitreous body. Freely fi¬ltered at the glomerulus but poorly reabsorbed. Because |
Increased serum sodium concentration. Leads to increase in serum tonicity, leading to diffusion of intracellular fluid into the intravascular space, decreasing cerebral oedema. |
| Physiological effects | ↓ICP/IOP |
CNS: Decreased cerebral oedema, decreased ICP, may cause central pontine myelinolysis CVS: Fluid shift into intravascular compartment increases plasma volume and may improve preload |
| Absorption | IV only. |
IV. |
| Distribution | Biphasic – plasma and ECF. |
— |
| Volume of distribution | 0.47 L/kg |
— |
| Metabolism | Not metabolised to a clinically significant extent. Excreted unchanged in urine. |
Unmetabolized |
| Excretion | Urine (~55% to 87% as unchanged drug) |
renally excreted |
| Half-life | Term half life: 4.7 hrs |
— |
| Adverse Effects Toxicity | Usually rare and idosyncratic. It may cause symptoms of pulmonary hypertension. |
1. Central pontine myelinolysis |
| Class Group | Diuretic - Osmotic |
Crystalloid |
| Indications Uses | 1. reduce CSF volume -> reduce ICP |
1. Treatment of severe, symptomatic hyponatraemia |
| Introduction | an alcohol derived from Dahila tubers (6 carbon decrease ICP: 0.25g/kg over 15min to 1g/kg PROS & CONS – See BELOW |
Hypertonic Crystalloid PROS & CONS – See BELOW |
| Legacy Cicm Level | Level 3 |
Level 1 |
| Presentation | Sterile 10% and 20% aqueous solutions. Crystallisation may occur at low temperatures. |
3%, 5% and 23.4% |
| Route And Dose | 1-2gm/kg IV |
— |
| Special Points | Osm (20%) 1100 ADVANTAGES: DISADVANTAGES: |
Osm 900 Na 450 ADVANTAGES: DISADVANTAGES: |
Past papers
Exam appearances
| Exam | Exact exam wording | Candidate success |
|---|---|---|
| 2015A Q10 | Compare and contrast the pharmacology of mannitol and hypertonic saline | 8% |