Past Papers · SAQ
Hartmann’s vs Saline
2023B Q18
Exam questionCompare and contrast the pharmacology of Hartmann’s solution and 0.9% saline?
CICMWrecks answer
Master answer
Master Compare
Compare candidate-facing canonical Pharmacopeia fields side by side. Isolated AI-draft proposals are never included.
| Field |
HARTMANN’s (CSL)
Fluids & Electrolytes · Fluids & Electrolytes · Level 1
|
NORMAL SALINE
Fluids & Electrolytes · Fluids & Electrolytes · Level 1
|
|---|---|---|
| Mechanism of action | — | 1. Plasma volume expander |
| Physiological effects | CVS The haemodynamic effects of Hartmann’s solution are proportional to GU Renal perfusion is temporarily restored towards normal in hypovolaemic patients transfused with the crystalloid. Metabolic/other 1 l of one-sixth molar sodium lactate is potentially equivalent to 290 ml of 5% sodium bicarbonate in its acid-neutralizing effect and |
— |
| Absorption | IV. BA 100% |
IV. BA 100% |
| Distribution | initially distributed into the plasma but |
~15mins: |
| Metabolism | - The lactate component is oxidized in the liver to bicarbonate |
Unmetabolized |
| Excretion | Excretion Via the urine. |
Excreted by kidney |
| Adverse Effects Toxicity | The predominant hazard is that of overtransfusion, leading to hypernatraemia, pulmonary oedema, and metabolic |
1. Fluid overload |
| Class Group | Crystalloid |
Crystalloid |
| Indications Uses | 1. in the treatment of dehydration |
1. Initial replacement fluid, in volume depleted or dehydrated patients. Volume depletion may be due to loss of blood, plasma or fluid and electrolytes. |
| Introduction | Compound sodium lactate |
intravenous fluid with 9g NaCl in litre of sterile water. |
| Legacy Cicm Level | Level 1 |
Level 1 |
| Presentation | As a clear, colourless sterile solution in 500/1000 ml bags |
500 or 1000mls of 0.9% Sodium Chloride solution in a collapsible plastic flask or bag. |
| Special Points | pH 6.5 (6-7.3) Na 131 |
pH 5.0 Na 154 |
Past papers
Exam appearances
| Exam | Exact exam wording | Candidate success |
|---|---|---|
| 2023B Q18 | Compare and contrast the pharmacology of Hartmann’s solution and 0.9% saline? | 17% |